Barstool College Football Show

Host rankings

Ranked by Guessperts Rank, counting only picks made on this show.

Guessperts Rank	Host	Record (W-L-P)	Win %	Guessperts Rating
1	Kayce Smith	11-6-0	65%	56.8%
2	Big Cat	13-10-0	57%	53.5%
3	Dave Portnoy	11-9-1	55%	52.5%
4	Brandon Walker	8-12-0	40%	45.0%
—	Ohio's TateContributor	Unranked — no decided picks yet

All episodes from this show.

Title	Date
Barstool College Football Show's Newest Co-Host?!?! \| Barstool College Football Show Week 5	2026-10-01
Brandon Walker Finally Has A Good College Football Team? \| Barstool College Football Show Week 4	2026-09-24
Is Michigan For Real? Lane Kiffin's Revenge Game, & More! \| Barstool College Football Show Week 3	2026-09-17
LIVE FROM ANN ARBOR, MI FOR #11 OKLAHOMA VS MICHIGAN \| Barstool College Football Show Week 2	2026-09-12
LIVE FROM BLOOMINGTON, IN FOR NORTH TEXAS VS #6 INDIANA \| Barstool College Football Show Week 1	2026-09-05

Latest picks from this show.

Host	Game	Pick	Result	Watch
Brandon Walker	Missouri @ Mississippi State	Mississippi State -6.5	Win	00:05:17
Dave Portnoy	Missouri @ Mississippi State	Mississippi State -6.5	Win	00:05:52
Big Cat	Missouri @ Mississippi State	Over 58.5	Loss	00:07:24
Kayce Smith	Missouri @ Mississippi State	Mississippi State -6.5	Win	00:08:41
Dave Portnoy	Iowa @ Michigan	Michigan -5.5	Loss	00:09:48
Brandon Walker	Iowa @ Michigan	Under 38.5	Loss	00:10:42
Big Cat	Iowa @ Michigan	Iowa +5.5	Win	00:11:28
Kayce Smith	Iowa @ Michigan	Iowa +5.5	Win	00:12:19
Big Cat	Ole Miss @ Florida	Over 58.5	Win	00:14:12
Brandon Walker	Ole Miss @ Florida	Under 58.5	Loss	00:15:43

21 Picks Pending until their games are decided.

We’ll reveal the full picks, results, and watch info once these games are complete.